The builder's rate buydown: what you're really buying
By Brandon · October 29, 2026
A brand-new house with a mortgage rate well below the market can beat a resale on the monthly payment. Here is what the low rate costs, who it works for, and what it does to the homes next door.
- Builders would rather lower your rate than lower the price. A dollar spent on the rate cuts the payment more, and the recorded price stays high.
- Around Charleston, the typical new home has sold for about $425,000 every year since 2022 while the whole market rose about 22%. New homes went from costing more than the typical home to costing less.
- A buydown pays off if you keep the loan for years. If you sell or refinance within a few years, a lower price would have left you better off.
- If you own a resale home in a neighborhood where the builder is still selling, the builder's payment is your competition. It weighs on your price, though usually by less than the builder spent.
How a buydown works
A buydown is money paid up front to the lender in exchange for a lower interest rate. When a builder pays it, the money comes out of the builder's pocket, but the cost is built into the deal: it is money the builder could have taken off the price instead.
There are two kinds.
- Permanent. The lower rate lasts for the life of the loan. Builders get these at a better price than a single buyer could by locking in large blocks of future loans with a lender ahead of time. It is the most expensive kind, often several percent of the price.
- Temporary. The most common is the "2-1." The rate is 2 points lower in year one, 1 point lower in year two, and back to the full rate from year three on. It costs the builder about 2% of the price. Lenders must check that you can afford the full payment, not just the year-one payment.
Why builders like it
Two reasons. First, a dollar spent on the rate lowers the monthly payment more than a dollar off the price. On the numbers below, the same builder budget cuts the payment by $378 a month as a buydown but only $157 as a price cut. Matching the buydown with a price cut alone would take roughly 14% off the price.
Second, the price on the deed stays high. That recorded price becomes the comparison for the next appraisal in the neighborhood and for every resale that follows. A price cut would reset the neighborhood. A buydown doesn't.
It is not a small business. In September, about two in three builders nationally were using sales incentives, while fewer than four in ten were cutting prices, according to the National Association of Home Builders. Among the largest builders, about 64% of sales in mid-2025 came with a permanent buydown, compared with about 13% for smaller builders, according to an American Enterprise Institute analysis. Lennar, one of the biggest builders in the Charleston area, reported spending about 12% to 14% of its sale prices on incentives over the past year.
What Charleston's numbers show
Zillow tracks the typical sale price of newly built homes in the Charleston area alongside the typical price of all homes sold. Here is the gap between the two, year by year.
In 2022 a new home cost about 15% more than the typical home sold here. This year it costs about 8% less. The typical new home has sold for about $425,000 every year since 2022, while the typical home overall climbed from about $380,000 to about $464,000.
Part of that gap is mix: new homes here are increasingly smaller and farther out, in places like Summerville, Goose Creek, Moncks Corner and the Cane Bay and Nexton areas. But a sticker price that hasn't moved in four years while everything around it rose is what you would expect to see when builders hold prices and do their discounting through the rate.
The national numbers point the same way. In September, builders had 476,000 new homes for sale, or 8.4 months' worth at the current sales pace, according to the Census Bureau, well above the roughly six months usually considered balanced. About 111,000 of those were already finished and waiting for a buyer. The median new home sold for $400,400, down about 4% from a year earlier. A builder carrying finished houses has every reason to make a deal, and the rate is usually where the deal shows up.
The buyer's math
Take a $425,000 new home, 10% down, and a market rate of 7.24% (Freddie Mac's 30-year average on October 29). Say the builder has about $25,500 to spend, 6% of the price.
| The builder spends it on… | Monthly payment |
|---|---|
| Nothing (full price, market rate) | $2,607 |
| A permanent buydown to about 5.7% | $2,230 |
| A $25,500 price cut, market rate | $2,450 |
| A 2-1 temporary buydown (about $9,000) | $2,110, then $2,353, then $2,607 from year three |
Principal and interest only. Taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues and mortgage insurance come on top.
On the payment, the buydown wins easily. Now look at what happens next.
If you keep the loan seven years or more, the buydown and the price cut come out about even, and the buydown slightly ahead. The lower payment adds up.
If you sell after three years, say the house is worth what it would have sold for without the incentive, about $399,500, and selling costs about 6%. The buydown buyer walks away with about $8,700. The price-cut buyer walks away with about $27,200. The buydown buyer borrowed more against a house that was never really worth the price on the deed.
If rates fall to 6% and you refinance after three years, the low rate you paid for is gone. You are left with the bigger loan, and your new payment would be about $2,290 a month, compared with about $2,173 for the buyer who took the price cut.
What about mortgage insurance? With less than 20% down, a conventional loan carries private mortgage insurance, often around 0.5% of the loan a year for a buyer with good credit. In this example that is about $175 a month on the buydown loan and $165 on the price-cut loan, close enough not to change the comparison. On paper the buydown buyer even sheds it sooner: it drops off by law once the loan is scheduled to reach 78% of the original price, about 8.3 years in versus 9.8, because the lower rate pays the loan down faster and the countdown runs from the higher price on the deed. The catch comes if you try to drop it early. A lender can ask for proof the home hasn't lost value, and an appraiser who values it at what it would have sold for without the incentive can sink the request. Removing it early because prices rose also takes longer, since the home started out worth less than the deed says.
FHA loans, which builders often steer first-time buyers toward, work differently: 1.75% of the loan up front plus about 0.5% a year. With 10% down it lasts 11 years. With less than 10% down it lasts for the life of the loan unless you refinance. Either way, rising home values don't remove it early.
So a buydown is a bet that you will stay put and that rates won't fall much. If that is your plan, it can be a good deal. If you might move for a job in a few years, or you are counting on refinancing, a lower price usually holds up better.
If you already own a home nearby
This is the part that gets less attention. If you own a resale home in a neighborhood where the builder is still selling, your buyer's other option is the builder's model home with a 5.7% rate. Many buyers shop by monthly payment, and on that measure you are up against a payment you can't match with a modest price cut.
How much does it cost you? Usually less than the builder spent. A lower rate is worth its full cost only to a buyer who keeps the loan for years. To someone who expects to move or refinance in two or three years, $25,000 of buydown is worth more like $8,000 to $12,000. Research on buyers taking over a seller's low-rate mortgage, the closest real-world test, found that only about a third of the rate's value showed up in the price. Appraisal rules point the same way: appraisers are told to subtract what an incentive actually added to a sale price, not its full cost.
Two things decide how long the pressure lasts.
- The build-out. The competition lasts as long as the builder has lots left, and it is often sharpest near the end, when builders clear the last homes or open a new phase. Once the neighborhood sells out, you are back to competing with other resales.
- Rates. If rates fall, the gap between the builder's rate and the market rate narrows, buydowns get cheaper, and builders need fewer of them. If rates rise, builders spend more to hold their advertised rate, and the pull on nearby resales gets stronger.
A resale has advantages too: it is finished, with the blinds, fence and landscaping a new-home buyer often pays thousands more for. Its lot may be better and its trees grown. And it can be bought with any lender. Cash buyers and buyers putting a lot down get little from a lower rate. If you have an FHA or VA loan at a low rate, a buyer may be able to take it over, which is a buydown of your own.
Questions worth asking
- What is the price of this home with no incentive, and how much would the builder take off the price instead of buying down the rate?
- Is the low rate permanent, or does it step up? What is the payment in year three?
- Do I have to use the builder's lender to get it, and how does that lender's rate and fees compare with an outside quote?
- How many lots are left in this neighborhood, and how fast are they selling?
- How long do I really expect to keep this loan?
How I did the math
Payments are principal and interest on a 30-year fixed loan with 10% down. The permanent buydown assumes the builder's 6% of price buys about 1.5 points off the rate. Builder pricing varies, and some get more. The three-year sale assumes the home is worth the no-incentive price less the incentive, with no price change and 6% selling costs. The value of the payment savings to a buyer is discounted at 7% a year. Mortgage insurance assumes 0.55% a year on a conventional loan and current FHA premiums. The new-home and all-homes prices are Zillow's typical sale prices for the Charleston metro area, using the median of each year's monthly values. National figures are from the Census Bureau and HUD's new residential sales report (September 2026, released October 27), the National Association of Home Builders (September 2026), the American Enterprise Institute (2025), Lennar's public reports, Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, and Sirmans, Smith and Sirmans (1983).
See it in the data
The Beacon shows the math and the questions worth asking. It is general information, not advice about any one person's decision.